Wednesday, September 22, 2010

What is Worship?

I am currently working on an in depth series of posts on this subject. Right now I am doing a lot of word studies in the OT and NT to find out how the Israelites and the early church viewed this subject.

Here are some things to think about in regards to worship. I will hopefully be discussing all of these questions/issues throughout this series on worship.
  1. What is worship?
  2. When do we worship?
  3. How do we worship?
  4. Why do we worship?
  5. What do we worship?
  6. Is music worship?
  7. Is music the only way to worship?
  8. does all music a Christian listens to/plays need to be worship?
  9. does all Christian music need to be worship?
  10. the difference between corporate and individual worship.
  11. How did the Israelites worship?
  12. What can we learn/apply from the OT temple worship system?
  13. How did the early church worship?
  14. Does the NT propose a new "worship" then the OT?
  15. What can we learn from the early church/NT about worship?
  16. Does God accept any and all forms of worship?
  17. Are there specific ways in which God wants us to worship him?
  18. Are there ways in which God does not want us to worship him?
I am sure there are other good questions that need to be asked as well. If you can think of any yourself, please post them as a reply. It will help me to develop my ideas and perhaps give me some directions to pursue I have not yet considered.

Tuesday, September 7, 2010

The importance of developing a philosophy of music

The necessity of having a thought out philosophy of music is a subject I briefly touched on in my last post and would like to discuss in further detail now. Why is it important that we have a philosophy regarding music ministry? Is it something we can do without? I believe that much of the confusion regarding music standards in the church could be solved if every pastor, musician, and church were to take the time to develop their philosophy regarding music and the church. It of course would not result in all churches and pastors agreeing on music standards, but I do believe it would help all of us to understand exactly where we stand and why, thereby giving us a way to communicate clearly and effectively our views in this area. Unfortunately today most churches today (and most pastors) have not given this issue the time or thought it needs. This leads to the following problems.
  1. A church without a philosophy of music ministry will base their music standards and choose music to be used in church based on personal preference; not on biblical precept or principle.
  2. Without a philosophy of music, music standards will not make sense and will either be abandoned or cause many to leave the church in frustration.*
  3. Without a philosophy of music our worship services will be haphazard and lack any clear purpose.
  4. Without a philosophy of music it will be hard to create a standard that makes sense. This often leads to different people in the church/ministry applying the music standards in completely different ways. **
But not only are there problems with not having a philosophy of music, there are also many benefits of having one.
  1. When we have a philosophy of music for the church it gives us a solid foundation upon which to build our music standards.
  2. This means when we are asked why we do or do not use a particular song or style in our services we will have a coherent answer to give the questioner based on our philosophy (which hopefully is based on biblical precepts and principles)
  3. It will help us give a purpose and unity to our service.
  4. It will help get everyone in the ministry on the same page regarding our music standards.
  5. It will help (not completely fix) us to not allow our personal preferences in music to dictate the standards that we set. (i.e. No CCM allowed, but all Southern Gospel is A-OK)
How then can a person/ministry develop a philosophy of ministry? First, one must be ready and willing to put a lot of thought and effort into the process, it will not be a quick five minute problem, it will most likely take weeks, months, or even years to develop fully. (And one should always be seeking to refine and better their philosophy, it is not something that once accomplished will never need to be thought about again.) Secondly it requires an open mind. We need to be willing to abandon our "pet" standards if we find they do not hold up to scriptural precept or principal. (I am not implying that they will not hold up, just that we need to be open minded enough that we are willing to change our views if necessary). Thirdly we need to do a careful study through scripture on music, worship, Christian liberty (with a focus on the needs of the "weaker" brethren), for principles and precepts that we can use to shape our philosophy.

One of the reasons I began writing this blog was to help me shape and develop my own philosophy of music. I have not yet figured it all out. Part of my purpose for this blog is to force myself to do what I am advocating here. In that vein of thought, sometime in the near future, I am going to be posting the results of some scriptural studies I am beginning on worship and music in both the NT and the OT to help us as we begin to develop a scriptural philosophy of music.As with all philosophies we develop for use in the church (i.e. philosophy of minstry, philosophy of youth ministry, philosophy of counseling, etc. etc.) we need to start at the source, the Bible, and work our way out from there. 


-------------------------------------------
* I think this is one of many areas in which a general unwillingness within IFB circles to truly explain the why's of our doctrines and practices is leading to the abandonment of our churches by youth today. Too often the answer is simply "because the Bible says so!" when we should be explaining how and where the Bible says so. I worry that the source of this reluctance is that many of us don't know why either, but do not want to find out why for fear of finding out we are wrong. Or, perhaps because we are too lazy to find out why and are content to accept "because the Bible says so" without actually looking to see if the Bible does say so. As I look back in the history of the fundamentalist movement I see that  many of the "fathers" of the movement were very intellectual and knew why they believed what they believed. However over the past generations, while the beliefs have been retained (although many times mutated)  the reasons have been lost and our beliefs are based on what our predecessors believed, not on our own careful study.

** The College I attended had very strict music standards. However, not everyone who "checked" the music applied the standards in the same way. It was common knowledge which Resident Managers to take your music to and which ones not to. A CD that wouldn't pass according to Miss. A, was considered perfectly fine by Mr. C, or Mrs. Q. I had a friend who was not allowed to sing specials in Sunday School for quite a while because his "style" did not pass. However, one day a certain person heard him sing (who had a good deal of influence in the music department) and suddenly he was one of the "favorites" for church and Sunday School specials. He didn't change his style, he merely was heard by someone who interpreted the "standards" differently.

Tuesday, August 31, 2010

Why do we remain silent?

Disclaimer: In this post, I am NOT advocating that we need to try to change the music standards or doctrine taught by our pastors. For the purpose of this post, I am assuming that the pastor's music standards are correct, but he is unknowingly (and innocently) using factually incorrect or misleading arguments to promote them.
------------------------

Something an anonymous person posted on my blog recently got me thinking. Why do we as church musicians sit and listen to sermons about music standards (for both church and home consumption) that make absolutely no sense, and never say anything to the pastor about it? Why do we allow our pastors (whom we admire and love) to continue to sound ignorant on a topic that we are so familiar with? Is this how we should be reacting? Should we sit and say nothing? Should we remain silent?

What am I talking about you may wonder? I am talking about the many sermons that I have heard (thankfully never from a pastor of a church I attend) where the preacher makes broad statements that make absolutely no sense if you understand anything about music. Such statements as: We don't use CCM because it is syncopated, and syncopation is a sign of rock music, or we don't use CCM because it uses a lot of "jazz" chords (usually they mean 7ths).

And yet any person who understands music theory and/or history will see that these statements are misleading or even just plain false.  Are pastors purposely using illogical arguments to get their point across? Are they intentionally misleading their congregation? I don't think so. Most of them are just repeating what they have read or heard on the issue. Where do such statements come from then? As I see it they come from two sources:
  1. musicians who, believing that most pastors and people could never understand the complexities of music theory, come up with a simplistic over generalized "rule" by which to measure music.
  2. People who, having a little bit of knowledge regarding music, see something that is true, but misapply that knowledge.  For example, Jazz theory is based in part on the use of 7th chords, so many come to the conclusion that 7th chords are Jazz and therefore are wrong. (My Sophomore music teacher had to straighten out a few of my fellow music students at college on this particular one). 
And yet a musician can tell you that syncopation is a part of almost all music, and even the "back-beat" type of syncopation can be found in Bach, Beethoven, and Brahms, and that 7th chords are used in all music, not just jazz.
So then why do we who know the silliness of such "rules" remain silent when our pastors preach them as truth? I think perhaps there are many reasons we remain silent.
  1. We don't want to contradict our pastor(s) and evangelists. 
  2. We agree with the pastor's ultimate standards of music, so we don't think it is really necessary to correct his erroneous reasons. After all he agrees with us in the end and that's all that matters.
  3. We really don't care
  4. We don't believe that our pastors could handle the truth 
  5. We are afraid of the possible outcomes of talking to the pastor about it. 
  6. We don't know why we have the standards we do, so we don't want to say anything, lest we get put in the hot seat. 
  7. We just don't want to take the time to articulate (or don't believe it necessary) a good thought out reason for our (and our pastor's) music standards.

I have to admit that I am guilty of remaining silent in these areas. And as I have been thinking about it, I have begun to think that perhaps I have been wrong in doing so. Some reasons why I think perhaps we ought to say something.
  1.  A wrong justification for a right action or standard will often lead to many abandoning that standard when they realize the justification they have been taught is not valid.
  2. I, who am called to be not only a musician but a pastor as well, would never want to be unknowingly say something foolish or untrue. (for example many pastors use illustrations in their sermons that are not factually accurate, it is easy to do, especially with the multitudes of "illustration" books available that do not check to make sure their facts/illustrations are accurate) If I were to proclaim a false fact I would want someone to tell me so I could not only apologize, but not repeat it.
  3. When we do not say something because we do not think others can handle the true complexity of the issue at hand (specifically music standards in this discussion) smacks of elitism and intellectual pride. If it is a difficult issue then we need to put the time and effort into finding a way to make it not as difficult, rather than coming up with a over-generalized broad statement that really isn't true.
  4. If our churches do not have an understandable legitimate set of standards to judge music by, they will abandon their standards when the current generation is no longer in charge.
  5. If a pastor sounds foolish and ignorant on one topic, many will begin to doubt the rest of what he says.
So then should we go up to our pastor after a message in which he says misleading things about music and confront him in front of everyone? Of course not. That will only create discord in the church and put the pastor on the defensive. But perhaps we should invite him out for lunch one day and discuss our concerns with him. This can be done in a gentle and considerate way, provided we have the right motives. (seeking to improve his ability to minister to his flock, rather than showing him up or proving him wrong)

There is one catch though. If we are going to inform our pastor that his reasons for his music standards don't make sense, then we need to be willing, ready, and able to provide him with reasons that do make sense. And this ultimately means that we personally need to understand why we hold the music standards that we do. If we do not know why, we need to figure it out. We as church musicians ought to have a clear philosophy of music that guides us in the music we use, the standards we hold, and the way in which we "perform". Until we know what our philosophy of music is (what, why, and how to keep true to it) we have no right to correct anybody on their erroneous reasons for their standards. And ultimately I think this is why we remain silent, because we don't know why we believe what we believe either, and we are afraid to let anyone know.

Tuesday, August 10, 2010

"Give Me That Old Time Religion"

How many of us have heard this song growing up in Conservative Christianity, either in our home church, on the radio, at the school/college we attended, etc. etc.?

Give me that old time religion
give me that old time religion
give me that old time religion
it's good enough for me.

And the verses are usually something like this:

It was good enough for Father [replace with mother, sister, grandpa, etc. for other verses]
it was good enough for Father
it was good enough for Father 
it's good enough for me.

Now, let me ask you this, have you ever actually thought about this song as you were listening to it? Have you ever considered what it is saying, what is meant when it is sung, or even whether or not we ought to sing it at all? I know when I first started thinking about what music is used in the church, this song quickly rose to the top of my list of songs I will never use in a worship service, will never use at a summer camp, will never listen to in the car, will never use period.

A few thoughts about this song.

1. What old time religion are we singing about?
  • the song never states which religion we want.
  • it could easily be talking about paganism (whose followers claim it is the oldest religion, btw)
  • or any other religion for that matter.
  • This song could easily be sung by anyone, a buddhist, a moslem, a pagan, etc. etc.
2. Why do we want this "old-time religion?"
  • according to this song we are Christians (or whatever religion we are) because it's the "good old religion"
  • according to the verses we are Christians (or whatever) because that's what our parents were.
  • thought doesn't seem to be important in this process. Just the fact that it's what my daddy believed, so that's what I'm going to believe.
  • according to the logic of this song we should just stay whatever religion our parents are, because it was good enough for them wasn't it?
3. Are we satisfied with it being "good enough"?
  • just because something is good enough for me, doesn't mean it is the best choice for me.
  • are we satisfied with the religion that is "good enough" or should we seek the one that is best?
And yet if I were to sing this song as a special in most conservative Baptist churches I would get a lot of hearty amens and pats on the back.  Very few would question the words or meaning of this song. Very few would wonder if we should be singing this song. Very few would question the song at all. They would just agree with the sentiment that we need to stick to the "good old-time religion" and not any of this new-fangled stuff. I have news for these people. There was a time Christianity was considered the "new religion." Could the early church have sung this song? Most of them were ostracized and even disowned by their parents for believing in that "new-fangled" religion. According to this song you should stick with whatever religion your parents follow, whether it's buddhism, taoism, paganism, islam, satanism, etc. etc. What matters is it is the good old time religion that our parents follow. According to this logic then the early Christians should have just stayed Jewish or pagan, and not switched to this "new" religion.

But even more importantly this song completely misrepresents why we should be a Christian. If you are a Christian merely because it's the "Old-time religion" or because "it was good enough for Father" then you really aren't a Christian, are you? To truly be a Christian one must make a conscience choice to accept the work of Christ upon the cross for redemption of our sins.  It is a personal choice, not something we are born into, and if we choose to be a Christian merely because it's the good old religion, then we don't even truly understand what Christianity is, nor are we truly saved!

So then why do we sing this song? Why do we fill our children's heads with ideas that directly contradict scripture? I want my children to choose Christianity because they understand that they are a sinner, that the punishment for sin is death, that their works will never make them righteous enough for God, that the only payment for our sin is death, that Jesus Christ died on the cross to pay for our sins, and that he rose again victorious over the grave. I do not want them to choose Christianity merely because Daddy is a Christian.

I think the answer to why we sing this song lies in the fact that it expresses the true reason many of us do many of things we do (especially those things we do in the church) for specifically this reason. We've always done it this way, it's the good old fashioned way, and we aren't a a part of the "new" crowd. I however submit that we should never do anything merely because it is the way it's always been done. If the people who started doing it had thought that way, it would never have been done in the first place! Furthermore, how do we know that it is right? The ones who started doing it could have been wrong! God help us if we do wrong the first time! I personally am glad that Martin Luther, John Calvin, Martin Zwingli,, Menno Simons, John Smith, John Huss, Wycliffe, Tyndale and many others didn't stick with the "old-time religion" of their parents or the accepted institution known as the church in their day. We as Christians and musicians ought to be testing everything we do according to the standard of the Word of God, not the standard of time, or acceptability in our "circles".

Why am I a Christian? I can tell you one thing for sure: it is not because it's the good old-time religion that was good enough for my parents.

Tuesday, July 27, 2010

Throwing the Baby Out WIth the Bathwater

This past weekend I visited and candidated at a church that was looking for a music director. And whether or not I and they decide I am right for the job I learned a lot and had a wonderful experience there. The church does not have what I would consider a contemporary worship service. (And no CCM fan would consider it a contemporary service either). Yet, I know many IFB's (Independent Fundamental Baptists) who would have condemned them as going contemporary. Why? Because of a few methods that they use.

They only used a piano (Keyboard on grand piano setting) for the accompaniment of the congregational singing, and the  "soundtracks" (for lack of a better word) were recorded on a Yamaha synthesizer by the church pianist, and would be considered by most as very conservative in instrument choices and lack of heavy rhythm. However, there were many aspects of their song portion of the service that many IFB's would have been upset over. 
  1. The format of the worship service: They sang the songs in 2 groups of 3 songs without a break between the songs in each section, they just went straight into the next song.
  2. They used song sheets, instead of hymnals. 
  3. They used prerecorded "sound tracks" for their accompaniment of singing groups. 
  4. They used keyboards instead of actual pianos. 
  5. The song leader was joined by a group of 6 church members on stage to lead the singing. (they did not call it a worship team because of the associations with that phrase) 
  6. They used some songs that were at one time popular CCM songs. (mainly from the 1980's). 
  7. the group held microphones while leading singing.

Now, there are many who would condemn this church for going "contemporary", but the truth of the matter is that they haven't. They are merely using different methods then they used to use. They had very good reasons for everything that they did.
  1. They changed the format of their song service because they noticed a lot of "dead" time between each song. They are now able to sing more in less time than before when they announced each song separately and waited for everyone to find the song in the hymn book. In addition they have found that this new format seems to lend itself to creating an atmosphere conducive to worship better than the old way. 
  2. Because of the change in format, hymnals were no longer practical. They still have them, and sing only songs in their hymnal, but they use the song sheets to once again get rid of dead time in the service. They wanted to use a projector screen, but due to the shape of their sanctuary this was impractical.
  3. They used pre-recorded sound tracks because they needed the pianist in their singing groups. However, because they were having trouble finding conservative enough sound tracks to buy, they began creating their own with the Yamaha synthesizer. 
  4. They used keyboards instead of pianos because they were having to tune their piano at least 4 times a year (sometimes even more!) due to the climate variation in their location and after the initial investment, keyboards are more cost effective for them. 
  5. They had the group lead singing because they noticed that once the choir was disbanded (they didn't have anyone to lead it anymore) the congregational singing was dead and really only served the purpose of filling time. Now that they have 6 people lead singing (singing parts) the congregational singing is alive and vibrant, and is now more than just a time-filler, it is a vibrant and important part of their worship service. 
  6. They used old CCM songs that were good theologically sound and beautiful songs (especially once stripped of the CCM trappings). They also used the "old" hymns as well, and it was a good mixture that really lended itself to worship. 
  7. Their sound man insisted they used microphones so that he could get better recordings of the service.

I personally like using hymnbooks better than song sheets, but that is only because I like to be able to sing the parts, and song sheets with words only don't allow me to do that as easily. I personally prefer using a piano over a keyboard, because no matter how good a keyboard is, it just can't compare to a Steinway 9 ft grand piano. I also like live accompaniment rather than sound tracks because it gives much more flexibility to the singers and instrumentalists. However, in this church I would agree that their choices in these matters were not only acceptable, but the best choice given the talents they had and their situation. In truth their group that helped lead singing was no different than having a 200 member choir behind the music director (with area microphones) helping bolster the sound. Yet this very method is the one I am certain would be the most offensive to many IFB's. (In fact they had their music director leave the church over it).

What then would many have against the way this church did their music? There are many who would claim some or all of the methods I mentioned are "CCM" and shouldn't be used by good IFB's. And, yes it is true that these methods are often used by "contemporary" churches in their worship services, but that does not necessarily make them wrong. Just because they were even the ones who first started doing some of these things does not make them wrong. We as church musicians need to be careful that we do not throw the baby out with the bathwater. When we are looking at an idea for use in the worship service our question should not be, "Does the CCM church down the road do this?" (And if they do I shouldn't!) Our question should be "Is there something wrong with this particular method?: Biblically or Practically?  If not, then we should at least be willing to consider it and should weigh the positives vs. the negatives. Change for the sake of change is not a good reason, but neither is staying the same because that's the way we've always done it. There are some good, useful ideas (and even songs) that have come out of the Contemporary movement, and we need to be able to look at them carefully and be able to realize that just because a CCM church started it doesn't make it wrong. Just because the pope is against abortion doesn't mean I am for it.

Let's at least be open to considering and thinking about new ideas and methodology in our church music and the use of it in the worship service. Just because we adopt or use a method first used by a "CCM" church does not make us a "CCM" church, neither does refusing to do it make us a good "IFB" church. Instead of using our traditions and preferences to dictate what we believe is right and wrong, let's use the Bible to guide us in our decisions about the music and methods we as church musicians use in the worship service.

Friday, July 23, 2010

Southern Gospel vs ..CCM

One of the most confusing things for me, as a musician is trying to figure out the logic behind many conservative Christians (especially us Baptists) who preach long and hard against all forms of CCM music, and yet view Southern Gospel Music (of all kinds) as the music of heaven. Many of the very arguments they use against the "CCM movement" could easily be used (and justifiably so) against Southern Gospel. I recently visited a church that was looking for a youth pastor, and they and I were considering whether or not I was right for the job. During the interview with the pastor and the assistant pastor, it was very clear that this church took a strong stand against CCM music of any kind. They stayed away from that "wordly" music. However, they loved Southern Gospel.

Well, I visited the church a few days later for the Sunday Morning service, and then the Wednesday Evening Service, and I got to experience their idea of good godly music. I was actually surprised. The choir sang to a tape/cd accompaniment and it had a very strong rhythm, in fact I would say most of the track was rhythm. As I was sitting there in the service listening to this music I could not help but wonder why they were so against CCM and yet had no trouble with the music they were using. The backbeat was very strong, the lyrics were so shallow a 4 year couldn't have drowned, and I could barely hear the words because the music was so loud (especially the rhythm).

And yet if you were to ask the pastor why he is against CCM, most likely his answers would have been too much rhythm, shallow words, can't understand what is being sung, too worldly, too showy, etc. etc. And yet I could easily take all of their arguments against CCM and use them just as effectively or more-so against Southern Gospel. (especially the kind they were using).

Some will point to the lives of the CCM artists, but the same can be said of Southern Gospel. Some will say CCM is all about the performer and not about God, but once again this can be said of Southern Gospel! In many ways CCM and Southern Gospel are similar, and many in the Christian music business are involved in both! So why is CCM so evil, and Southern Gospel so good? The more I study, listen, and think about this the more confused I get, or rather I should say the more I see how confused most Conservative Baptists are on the issue.

My point is not to demonize Southern Gospel music, or any type of music. I simply want to get us to think about why we take the stands we do. Our position on CCM music ought to be reflected and mirrored in our position on Southern Gospel. Why is the bass and drums okay in Southern Gospel, but wicked and ungodly when used in CCM? Why are shallow lyrics such a turnoff for CCM, but A-okay in Southern Gospel? I am not saying that we can or cannot use Southern Gospel or CCM in our churches that is not the point of my questions. Rather, I am calling for consistency in the way we apply our philosophy of music in the church. One of the greatest turn offs to the younger generation regarding church is hypocrisy. I think that there is much hypocrisy in church music today. We need to apply the same standards to our music as we do to the younger generations music. Only when we are consistent will they be willing to listen to what we have to say.

Friday, November 20, 2009

Morality in Music

Some of the most crazy arguments turn up when answering the question, "Can music itself (without the words) have a moral or immoral aspect to it, or is music itself amoral (and the words are what determines morality)? Both sides of the CCM debate suffer from faulty arguments in this area. CCM proponents claim that since music is made of notes, and musical notes in themselves are neither good or evil, that means music must be amoral. The other side claims such things as electric bass guitars stimulate girl's sexual impulses, rock music must be evil because it kills houseplants, etc. etc. and when you get down to it they usually believe that only their preferred styles of music are morally good, and all other styles of music are morally evil.

Unfortunately neither of these responses actually deals with the question at hand. The proponents of CCM use faulty logic, and their opposition uses faulty science. So what then is the answer to the question? First to deal with the argument based on the notes being amoral and therefore music is amoral is logically flawed. Would one be willing to use the same logic applied to words, or pictures? If we did we could ask if the letter "e" was good or evil, and the answer is of course not. So taken to the same conclusion as in the musical argument that means that all books, poems, lyrics to songs (yes this does kind of kill the other point to their argument that the words are what determines morality, not the music), essays, newspaper articles, web blogs, etc. etc. are also completely amoral. What determines the morality of a piece of literature? The message that it is communicating. If it is a trashy romance novel full of drugs, sex, and violence it is an immoral book. But, if it is a book written to help believers grow in their Christian walk than we would say it is a "good" (or moral) book.

How many times have we heard it said that music is the universal language? (I do not completely agree with this statement, but, I will deal with that later in the post). If asked almost anyone will agree that music is a language of sorts. It communicates something to the hearer. "Song A" will make one want to jump for joy while "Song B" will make him want to cry! Why is this? Some music makes one lethargic while other music gives energy, some cheers us up, while other music depresses us. And words are not even necessary for these reactions. So we can say that music does communicate a message to the hearer just as words communicate a message to the reader or listener. The difference is that music can only communicate a general idea (usually emotion)  while words can communicate very specific ideas, instructions and thoughts. I do not believe it is a stretch to say that the morality of a piece of music can be tied to the emotions that that music evokes. If a piece of music makes you angry or depressed should you listen to it? Or should it be used in a church setting? Should it be used in "Christian" music? These are some of the questions we need to be asking ourselves.

The true difficulty of this then is not the question of whether or not music is amoral, but how to decide what music is good and what music is bad (in the moral sense, not the artistic sense). Often this is where the anti-CCM crowd begins to trip up. They begin to preach their preferred styles of music as being what is moral and all other styles as being immoral. Many vault the western classical era (Baroque through Romanticism) as being the pinnacle of music and what is good and moral. (I am not demeaning classical music, I personally love classical music but I also don't think it is the only good music) Others only accept music in the church that has been around for at least 20, 50 or 75 years. So a song that was considered "wrong" 20 years ago is now accepted by the very people who lambasted it earlier. Certain musical ideas or performance methods are preached against, then accepted 10 years later by the same crowd. (Using a microphone, using a guitar, drumbeat, backbeat, etc. etc.) Often the idea you get is that if it doesn't line up with what they like it must be wrong. The gamut is wide of what is preached, taught, and believed about what musical styles are good and what musical styles are evil. Music from other cultures and countries is often demonized and missionaries have even been known to try to force western musical tastes upon the people they are trying to reach. Is western music the only good music? Is our tonal system the only good tonal system? Are our ideas of meter and musical expression the only ones that God enjoys?

To say that music is the universal language is false, for every culture has it's own style of music. Just like spoken and written languages some musical languages are more closely related than others. Spanish and Portuguese are not the same language, but they are similar in many ways. Spanish and Japanese have very little in common. This is often true of music as well. And just like with written and spoken languages, one must be fluent in a musical langauge to understand what is being communicated. That means that an Independent, Fundamental Baptist from the U.S. might not be able to understand what is being said by music from another culture. Just because we do not understand it however (or like it) does not mean we ought to demonize it and proclaim it as wicked. There are also generational differences is musical language just as in spoken language. An eighty year old man does not usually speak the same as a 12 year old girl, even if they are from the same family! In fact there are many times when there are communication difficulties in such a situation. I think that we ought to at least consider the possibility that the same is true of music (History seems to show this is true, Bach's music was considered "worldly" and wrong by some of the "old-timers" of his day).

We must be careful that our ignorance of a type or style of music does not cause us to automatically dismiss it as immoral and wrong for a Christian. Instead, we need to carefully consider and think before making such bold statements. I am not saying that all styles of music are good and right, their are many styles of music that a Christian ought to be wary of, (because of what is being communicated and of course many other considerations as well) and stay away from. But, we also need to be open-minded enough that we do not allow our personal preferences to dictate what music we proclaim as good or evil. Nowhere does the Bible tell us what styles of music a Christian ought to listen to, but neither does it tell us which authors we ought to read, or what T.V. shows we ought to watch. These are all areas in which we are expected by God to use our discernment to decide. I am not asking Christians to accept all music as good and wholesome, I am just asking that we put some real thought and biblical discernment into what we believe and that we be able to biblically explain our positions regarding certain styles of music and even be willing to accept the fact that just because we don't like it doesn't make it wrong.